Escape Rooms Near New Albany, Ohio
New Albany has excellent dining, beautiful neighborhoods, and easy access to Columbus. What it doesn't have is an escape room worth talking about. For that, you drive 25 minutes north to Crooked Cottage in Delaware, Ohio — and you'll be glad you did.
Crabtree Manor — Built for People Who Appreciate Detail
New Albany visitors tend to gravitate toward Crabtree Manor, and it's easy to understand why. This is a Victorian murder mystery set inside a meticulously crafted manor — rich with period detail, layered storytelling, and puzzles that reward attention. There is a real, full-size casket inside the room. The mystery surrounding it is yours to unravel.
Constance Merriweather — portrayed by Amy Lay of Columbus's celebrated Shadowbox Live — is the figure at the center of the story. She's charming. She's dangerous. And she's left a trail of clues only the most observant groups will follow to the end.
Crabtree Manor accommodates up to 12 players, making it ideal for corporate outings, group date nights, or any occasion where you want an experience that feels genuinely theatrical.
Book Crabtree ManorAll Five Rooms — One Historic Building
Crooked Cottage isn't a franchise or a strip mall operation. It's a real historic building in downtown Delaware, Ohio — owned outright, built with intention, and home to five completely distinct escape room experiences. Every booking is private. The facility is unstaffed during your session, which means the immersion is complete from the moment the door closes.
Crabtree Manor
A Victorian murder mystery with a real full-size casket, a cast of suspects, and a story that rewards the detail-oriented. Our most theatrical room.
Up to 12 players
View roomHouse in the Woods
An isolated cabin with a deeply unsettling past. Suspenseful, atmospheric, and deeply satisfying to unravel.
Up to 8 players
View roomJoyce's Dollhouse
A paranormal investigation built around real unexplained hauntings in this building. A real name was found in the walls during renovation. Joyce Babcock hasn't left.
Up to 6 players
View roomMayan Temple
Ancient ruins, hidden chambers, and a race against a curse. Adventure-driven and endlessly replayable.
Up to 6 players
View roomWizarding University
Opening July 2026. A magical academy experience unlike anything else in central Ohio.
Up to 6 players — booking opens soon
Getting Here from New Albany
The drive from New Albany to Delaware is straightforward — about 25 minutes with no complicated routing. Take SR-161 West to US-23 North and you're there. Free parking directly at the building.
| From | Drive Time | Route |
|---|---|---|
| New Albany (central) | 25–30 minutes | SR-161 W to US-23 N |
| Easton Town Center | 25–30 minutes | SR-161 W to US-23 N |
| Gahanna | 30–35 minutes | SR-317 to US-23 N |
| Westerville | 15–20 minutes | US-23 N |
Pricing
Starting at $43.00 per person for 2 players, $39.00 per person for 3–4 players, and $35.00 per person for 5 or more players.
Corporate rate: $34.40 per person for team building events (20% off). Groups of 25+ receive an additional 15% off at $29.24 per person.
Planning a birthday outing from New Albany? Every birthday booking includes an exclusive swag bag for the guest of honor — a $50 value curated by Raven's Cauldron. Learn more.
Gift cards available. Learn more.
Frequently Asked Questions
How far is Crooked Cottage from New Albany?
About 25–30 minutes via SR-161 West to US-23 North. It's an easy, straightforward drive with free parking directly at the building when you arrive.
Which room is most popular with New Albany groups?
Crabtree Manor is our most requested room for groups coming from New Albany. It's a Victorian murder mystery with a full-size casket, rich storytelling, and puzzles that reward attention to detail. It accommodates up to 12 players, making it well-suited for group outings.
Do you offer corporate team building for New Albany businesses?
Yes — corporate groups receive 20% off at $34.40 per person, with an additional 15% off for groups of 25 or more ($29.24 per person). We can accommodate up to 38 players across all five rooms simultaneously. Learn more about corporate events.
Is the facility staffed during our session?
Yes, our gamemaster will guide you through everything and happily provide hints as needed.
Your group is private. We never put you with strangers. Every booking is exclusive to your group — no one else will be added to your session regardless of room capacity.
Do you accept walk-ins?
Online booking required. We do not accept walk-ins. Book in advance at the link above to reserve your time slot.
Is there anything else to do in Delaware after our session?
Downtown Delaware has a solid independent dining scene worth exploring before or after. Raven's Cauldron — our partner curiosity and crystal shop — is also nearby and worth a visit if you're curious about something a little different.